Phnom Penh, serving Cambodia and the region

Nitrogen & blowers

On-Site Nitrogen Generation vs Cylinders: When a PSA Generator Pays Off

Nitrogen generator vs cylinders: the cost drivers on each side, how to compare them fairly, and why feed-air quality decides how a PSA generator performs.

Nexus Turnkey Engineering Team6 min read

Steady demand favours generation; occasional use favours cylinders

An on-site PSA nitrogen generator usually pays off when three things are true. Your nitrogen demand is steady and significant. The purity you need sits within what a generator can deliver. And you count the full cost of cylinders, not just the price per cylinder. Cylinders, or liquid nitrogen, remain the sensible choice for low or occasional use, very high purity at small volume, or sites with no spare compressed air capacity.

There is a second rule that matters as much as the first. A generator is only as good as the compressed air fed into it. Dry, filtered, oil-controlled feed air decides its output, purity and life. This article explains the cost drivers on both sides, how to compare them fairly and how to protect a generator. It belongs to our industrial compressed air guide.

How on-site generation works

Air is about 78 percent nitrogen by volume. A generator removes most of the rest.

PSA (pressure swing adsorption). Compressed air passes through a vessel filled with carbon molecular sieve, which adsorbs oxygen faster than nitrogen. Nitrogen passes through. Before the sieve saturates, the flow switches to a second vessel while the first depressurises and releases its oxygen. The two vessels alternate continuously. Purity is adjustable: the higher the purity, the lower the nitrogen output from the same feed air.

Membrane separation. Membrane separation uses bundles of hollow fibres. Oxygen and water vapour permeate through the fibre walls faster than nitrogen, which leaves at the far end. Membranes are compact, quiet and have few moving parts. They are usually applied at moderate purities.

Manufacturers commonly quote PSA purities up to 99.999 percent. Membranes are generally used where lower purity is acceptable. Your process sets the target. Food packaging, electronics soldering, laser cutting, pharmaceutical blanketing and heat treatment each have their own requirement, and the right answer is the lowest purity that meets it.

The cost drivers on each side

Cost driverCylinders or liquid supplyOn-site generator
The gas itselfPrice per cylinder or per unit of liquidNone; nitrogen comes from air
EnergyBuilt into the supplier’s priceCompressed air: the main running cost
EquipmentCylinder or tank rentalCapital cost of generator, buffer vessel, treatment
LogisticsDeliveries, handling, storage spaceNone after installation
WasteGas returned unused in “empty” cylindersVenting during purity changes or low demand
MaintenanceRegulators and manifoldsFilters, valves, periodic sieve or membrane checks
Supply riskDelivery delays, changeover downtimeDepends on the compressor and generator staying up

Two items are often missed when cylinders look cheap.

  • Residual gas. Cylinders go back with gas still in them, because the last of the pressure cannot be used at the required flow. You paid for that gas.
  • Changeovers. Every cylinder change takes labour, risks air ingress into the line and can stop a process. In a packaging line, the cost of a stoppage may be larger than the cost of the gas.

And two are often missed when generators look cheap.

  • Compressed air is not free. It is one of the most energy-intensive utilities in a plant. A generator needs a reliable supply of treated air with spare capacity, or a dedicated compressor.
  • Redundancy. If production cannot run without nitrogen, plan backup: a second generator, a cylinder bank on standby or a buffer large enough to cover a short outage.

How to compare them fairly

A fair comparison puts both options on the same basis: cost per Nm³ of nitrogen delivered at the required purity, pressure and flow, over the same period.

  1. Measure actual use. Count cylinders delivered over several months and convert to Nm³. Better, meter the flow at the point of use.
  2. Fix the requirement. Required purity, pressure and peak flow, plus how demand varies by shift.
  3. Cost the cylinders in full. Gas, rental, delivery, handling labour, residual gas and stoppages.
  4. Cost the generator in full. Capital, installation, compressed air energy at your tariff, maintenance and backup.
  5. Compare over the equipment’s service life, not one month.

Our compressed air cost calculator helps estimate the energy cost of the feed air, which is usually the largest running cost of a generator. We don’t quote payback periods in advance, because they depend entirely on your measured use and tariffs. Savings are project-specific. We measure them against a baseline and verify them after implementation; we don’t promise a blanket percentage.

The number that matters is the cost of a cubic metre of nitrogen at the purity you actually need.

Feed-air quality decides generator performance

Carbon molecular sieve and membrane fibres are sensitive. Oil aerosol and vapour, liquid water and particles all reduce their performance, and some of that damage is permanent. A generator fed with poor air will lose output and purity over time, whatever its specification sheet says.

A typical feed-air train includes:

  • An aftercooler and water separator at the compressor
  • A dryer sized for site conditions, refrigerated or desiccant, to reach the required pressure dew point
  • Particulate and coalescing filters to remove dust, water and oil aerosol
  • An activated carbon filter where oil vapour must be controlled
  • Automatic drains that work reliably
  • A receiver to buffer feed-air demand

Cambodia’s climate makes this more important. Hot, humid intake air carries a heavy water load into the compressor, and high ambient temperature raises the temperature of the compressed air. Dryers and filters must be sized for the hottest, most humid conditions, not nominal ratings. Our article on refrigerated vs desiccant dryers covers the pressure dew point choice, and the equipment is on our air treatment page.

Sizing for peaks, not just the average

Nitrogen demand is rarely flat. Packaging machines draw in pulses, and several machines may start together after a break. A generator sized only for the average will fall short at peaks, and purity can dip if it is pushed beyond its rating. Sizing for the absolute peak, on the other hand, buys capacity that sits idle most of the day.

The usual answer is a generator sized near the average demand at the required purity, with a nitrogen buffer vessel large enough to cover the peaks. That needs real demand data: flow logged over representative shifts, not an estimate from machine nameplates. Fit an oxygen analyser at the generator outlet so purity is measured continuously, with an alarm and, where the process demands it, automatic diversion of off-specification gas. Allow for start-up time too, because a PSA generator takes a short period to reach purity after a stop.

Safety: nitrogen displaces oxygen

Where on-site nitrogen is used

Food and beverage plants use nitrogen for modified-atmosphere packaging and product protection; see our food and beverage page. Electronics plants use it in soldering and component storage; see our electronics page. Other users include pharmaceutical blanketing, laser cutting, heat treatment and fire prevention.

Start with the cylinder invoices

The simplest first step is to collect a few months of cylinder or liquid invoices and the purity your process needs. From that, we can size a PSA or membrane generator from the Nexus range, with capacities selected to your load (ask for a datasheet), and design the compressed air treatment that protects it. See our nitrogen generators page for the range.

Nexus Turnkey Engineering Team

Written and reviewed by the engineers who design, install and maintain industrial air systems for Nexus Turnkey in Cambodia. Questions about this article? Ask us directly.

FAQ

Questions engineers ask us

When does a nitrogen generator make more sense than cylinders?

Usually when nitrogen use is steady and significant, the purity you need is within what PSA or membrane generators deliver, and you count the full cost of cylinders: rental, deliveries, handling, gas returned unused and supply interruptions. Low or occasional use often stays with cylinders.

What purity can a PSA nitrogen generator deliver?

PSA generators cover a wide range, and manufacturers commonly quote purities up to 99.999 percent. Higher purity means less nitrogen from the same feed air, so specify the purity your process actually needs, not the highest available.

Why does feed-air quality matter so much?

PSA generators separate nitrogen with carbon molecular sieve, and membranes with fine hollow fibres. Oil, water and particles in the feed air can damage both, reducing output and purity permanently. The compressed air must be dried and filtered to the generator maker's stated inlet specification.

Is a membrane generator cheaper than PSA?

Membranes are simple and compact, with few moving parts, and suit moderate purities. PSA reaches higher purities and is generally the choice when purity is tight. Compare both on cost per cubic metre of nitrogen at your required purity and flow.

Next step

Turn this into a plan for your plant.

Send us your situation and an engineer will reply with the questions that matter and a sensible next step.

Start typing to search