Phnom Penh, serving Cambodia and the region

Compressed air

Fixed Speed vs VSD vs PM-VSD Compressors: Which Fits Your Demand Profile?

Fixed speed, VSD or PM-VSD? How each compressor drive follows demand, where each is efficient, and how to pick from a logged demand profile, not a brochure.

Nexus Turnkey Engineering Team6 min read

The demand profile decides, not the drive

A fixed-speed compressor is most efficient when demand is steady and close to its full output. A VSD (variable speed drive) compressor earns its keep when demand swings, because it slows down instead of running unloaded. A PM-VSD compressor is a VSD machine with a permanent-magnet motor, chosen for efficiency across a wide speed range. None of the three is best in every plant. Log your air demand for a full production week, then choose the drive, or the mix of drives, that fits the shape of that curve.

This article explains how each type controls its output, where each one wastes energy, and how to combine them. It belongs to our industrial compressed air guide.

How each one follows demand

Fixed speed: load and unload

A fixed-speed rotary screw compressor runs its motor at one speed. When pressure reaches the upper setpoint, it stops compressing and runs unloaded. When pressure falls to the lower setpoint, it loads again. This is load/unload control.

The weakness is unloaded power. The US Department of Energy’s compressed air sourcebook, produced with the Compressed Air Challenge, states that an unloaded rotary screw compressor will in most cases consume 15 to 35 percent of its full-load power while delivering no air. A machine that spends many hours unloaded is paying for air it never makes. A correctly sized receiver lengthens the load and unload cycles and reduces the waste, but it cannot remove it.

VSD: change speed

A VSD compressor uses an inverter to vary motor speed, so airflow follows demand while pressure stays within a narrow band. At part load, it draws less power instead of cycling.

There are two limits. First, at full output the DOE sourcebook notes that most VSD packages run above the optimum rotor tip speed, at reduced airend efficiency and higher input power than a comparable fixed-speed machine at its optimum. Second, every VSD has a minimum speed. The same source describes designs that stop at around 20 percent speed and others that unload at 40 to 50 percent, with unloaded power of 10 to 15 percent. Below that range, a VSD behaves much like a fixed-speed machine.

PM-VSD: change speed with a permanent-magnet motor

A PM-VSD compressor replaces the induction motor with a permanent-magnet synchronous motor, often coupled directly to the airend. Permanent-magnet motors generally keep their efficiency better at low speed than induction motors, which is where a variable-speed compressor spends much of its time. Ask for the motor’s IE efficiency class and, more importantly, the package’s specific power at several operating points.

The three side by side

Fixed speedVSDPM-VSD
How output follows demandLoads and unloadsMotor speed variesMotor speed varies
Most efficient whenSteady, near full loadDemand swings in mid rangeDemand swings over a wide range
Main weaknessPower drawn while unloadedSlight penalty at full load; minimum speedHigher purchase price; same minimum-speed limit
Best role in a hallBase loadTrim compressorTrim, or sole machine with a variable load

A variable-speed compressor saves energy only when demand varies. On a flat load at full output, fixed speed is the honest choice.

Read your demand profile first

Most plants have one of three demand shapes. Each points to a different answer.

Flat and high. Demand sits close to one compressor’s capacity for most of the shift. A fixed-speed machine sized to the load runs mostly loaded and wastes little. A VSD would rarely slow down.

Swinging. Demand moves up and down through the shift as lines start, stop and change over. Plants with many small, intermittent users often work this way. A single fixed-speed machine would spend much of its time unloaded. A VSD or PM-VSD sized to the swing will follow it.

Big base with a swing on top. Demand never falls below a large base, with a variable layer above it. This is the most common shape in multi-line plants. The efficient answer is usually fixed-speed machines on the base and one variable-speed machine trimming the rest.

To see the shape, log flow, pressure and power for at least a full production week. A compressed air audit does this, and gives you a baseline in kWh/m³ to measure any change against. Don’t skip nights and weekends. Off-production demand is usually leakage, and a VSD sized for leaks is a VSD sized for waste.

Combine them with a sequencer

In a hall with several compressors, control matters as much as the machines. Each compressor’s own controller only sees its own pressure. Left alone, machines with overlapping setpoints can all run part-loaded, or two variable-speed units can hunt against each other.

A sequencer or master controller solves this. It decides which machines run as base load, which one trims, and which stays on standby. The DOE sourcebook describes this arrangement: most compressors fully loaded on base load, with only one modulating as the trim machine. Our SCADA and monitoring work adds that overlay to existing halls, keeping each compressor’s own protections in place.

The trim machine should be sized so that its speed range covers the largest step in demand that the base machines cannot follow. If the trim compressor is too small, a base machine has to load and unload to fill the gap. If it is too big, it runs near minimum speed.

Tropical points to check

Variable-speed compressors carry power electronics. In a hot, dusty compressor room, check:

  • the maximum ambient rating of the package and of the drive cabinet;
  • the cabinet’s cooling path and filter, and how often the filter needs cleaning in the dry season;
  • tolerance to voltage dips and harmonics on your supply, and what protection is included;
  • the ventilation of the room itself, covered in our article on compressor room design for tropical heat.

How to compare offers

Ask each supplier for published package performance data, not just a nameplate. For a variable-speed machine, ask for specific power at several flows, for example 40, 70 and 100 percent of capacity, at your working pressure. Then weight those points by the hours your demand log shows at each flow. That weighted figure, multiplied by your electricity price, is the number that matters. Our compressed air cost calculator helps with the arithmetic.

Before you choose a drive type

  • Log flow, pressure and power for at least one production week
  • Identify base demand, swing and off-production demand
  • Repair major leaks and re-log if leakage is significant
  • Set the lowest workable header pressure
  • Ask for specific power at several operating points, at your pressure
  • Decide how the new machine will sequence with existing ones
  • Check ambient, dust and power-quality ratings of the drive

Savings are project-specific. We measure them against a baseline and verify them after implementation; we don’t promise a blanket percentage.

Choosing for your plant

If your plant runs one compressor and demand swings, a single right-sized variable-speed machine may be the whole answer. If you run several, the best result usually comes from the right mix and a sequencer, not from replacing everything. Our article on how to choose an air compressor covers the other decisions.

We supply fixed-speed, VSD and PM-VSD air compressors from Ingersoll Rand and Sollant as an authorised distributor. Ask us which series are currently supplied in Cambodia. Bring us a demand log, or ask us to make one, and we will show you which combination fits it.

Nexus Turnkey Engineering Team

Written and reviewed by the engineers who design, install and maintain industrial air systems for Nexus Turnkey in Cambodia. Questions about this article? Ask us directly.

FAQ

Questions engineers ask us

Does a VSD compressor always use less energy than a fixed-speed one?

No. A VSD saves energy when demand varies, because it slows down instead of running unloaded. At steady full load, the US DOE compressed air sourcebook notes that most VSD packages run above their optimum rotor speed and can use slightly more power than a comparable fixed-speed machine. The demand profile decides which is better.

What is the difference between VSD and PM-VSD?

Both vary the motor speed with an inverter. A PM-VSD compressor uses a permanent-magnet synchronous motor instead of an induction motor. Permanent-magnet motors generally hold their efficiency better across a wide speed range. Compare the published package data at your operating points rather than relying on the label.

Can I add a VSD compressor to a hall of fixed-speed machines?

Yes, and it is often the best arrangement. The fixed-speed machines run fully loaded on base load and one variable-speed machine trims the swing. It needs a sequencer, or a master controller, so the machines share pressure bands sensibly instead of fighting each other.

How long should I log demand before choosing?

At least one full production week, including nights, weekends and changeovers. If production is seasonal, as it is in many garment and agro-processing plants, log the high and low seasons or adjust for them.

Next step

Turn this into a plan for your plant.

Send us your situation and an engineer will reply with the questions that matter and a sensible next step.

Start typing to search